1. Home /
  2. Blog
  3. /
  4. Taxing Nations Savings At What Cost

Taxing nation’s savings: at what cost?

author Befiler date
Taxing nation’s savings: at what cost?

By Syed Asad Ali Shah

Budget 2022-23 is continuation of series of budgets for last several years that have been increasing tax rates and withdrawing exemptions, mostly raising the tax burden on the existing tax payers. Like all previous budgets, current one also aims to reduce the fiscal deficit that has remained in the range of 7 to 8% of the GDP during last two decades mainly through an attempt to increase revenue. However, in most cases, such approach has not worked in the past, as neither the revenue increased (in real terms) nor the deficit was contained.

One unique aspect of this budget is to do away rebates and allowances to retail investors for their investments in life & health insurance, voluntary pension schemes and mutual funds. Withdrawal of these rebates provided through sections 62 and 63 of the Income Tax Ordinance proposed by Finance Bill that will be voted upon by the National Assembly in next few days, tantamount to effectively taxing formal sectors that promote savings will be hugely counterproductive for the capital market, insurance and mutual fund sectors of the economy.

Chronic problems of Pakistan Economy

The above proposals, will further aggravate our economy’s deep-rooted problems briefly described below. 

  1. Rate of savings in Pakistan has remained very low, below 15% of the GDP, compared to other similar economies like Bangladesh & India, where rates of savings has remained between 28 to 30%. Due to paltry savings rate, the investment rates have also remained below 15%, as any additional investment has to be from borrowings or foreign direct investment, both of which have largely dried up owing to continuing fiscal and current account deficits and low investor confidence.
  1. Currently, Pakistan’s capital market is its lowest level, as the total market cap of all listed companies on PSX have fallen to only Rs. 7.1 trillion or around $ 34.6 billion, which means it is less than 10% of the GDP. At this level, both in absolute terms and as proportion of GDP, it has fallen to the lowest level that I can remember during the last 2 decades history.

Budget Proposals

Currently, under section 62 and 63 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, individuals are entitled to certain tax credits for making investments in mutual funds, life & health insurance, and contributions to approved pension schemes, which results in reduction in their tax liabilities within certain specified threshold.  It is these rebates & tax credits that the Finance Bill, 2022 proposes to remove. Withdrawal of these small incentives / tax rebates to retail investors will not only be counterproductive for these formal sectors -Life & health insurance, voluntary pension schemes, mutual fund industry and capital market as whole- but will also undermine savings & investments levels, which are already the lowest in the world. Moreover, the proposed amendments, together with increase in tax rates for salaried individuals, will cause further increase in the tax liability of the salaried class.

Life insurance and Mutual Funds are instruments through which savings are mobilized from retail investors for investment in productive sectors, especially the capital market. It may be noted that we hardly have less than 300,000 investors in the capital market compared to nearly 50 million in India- just 0.6% of the number of investors in India- which highlights serious gaps in our investment ecosystem.

Considering Pakistan’s paltry rate of savings (one of the lowest in the world) and lowest penetration of life & health insurance – less than 0.6% compared to 3% in India and global average of 3.7%- & market cap of Mutual Fund industry of barely 1.3% compared to 15% in India & over 50% in the world, this is a highly regressive step for the economy as a whole & especially the formal sectors of the economy.

Impact on FBR Revenue

The Government has estimated a tax saving of Rs. 3.9 billion as a result of withdrawal of these tax savings, but ignored the adverse impact of these withdrawals due to reduction in tax liability owing to reduced profitability of insurance companies and mutual funds and consequent reduction in dividend distributions by these entities that are also taxable in the hands of recipients. It may be noted that the insurance companies are taxed at much higher rates and dividends from such companies and mutual funds are also taxed.

At present the retail investor base in mutual funds industry is over Rs. 340 billion in open end schemes and over Rs. 39 billion in pension schemes, and majority of these investments are made by salaried individuals for availing tax benefits. Similarly a huge sum of insurance premium is paid by individuals towards and health and life insurance, which also qualify for tax rebates. Given the high interest rate and growing market base of insurance sector as a result of better financial awareness, these sectors should register a growth of at least 20% if not more, and it will directly impact the profitability and corporate tax to be collected from the companies, if these changes are not made. However, in case the proposed withdrawals are enforced, it will adversely impact the business of these entities eroding their profitability, and consequently their tax liabilities. In fact, there is a risk that even the existing consumers who no longer enjoy the benefit from these tax rebates may withdraw their investments / discontinue their insurance policies. The resulting loss of tax revenue from these corporate sectors will certainly outweigh the tax benefit expected from these tax savings.

Another important aspect that needs consideration is huge amount of investment by insurance companies and mutual funds in the capital market and money market. As per the estimate given by Insurance Association of Pakistan, aggregate investment by insurance sector is Rs. 2 trillion. As substantial portion of this comes from Life & health insurance, it may be assumed that 60% or Rs. 1.2 trillion investment is from Life & health insurance. Similarly, Rs. 200 billion out of total assets of mutual fund industry of around Rs. 1.2 trillion is invested in equity market. A natural consequence of reduced investments from retail investors in insurance and mutual funds will be reduction in their growth or stagnancy of these sectors, which means reduced flow to capital and money markets. As a result, there is serious risk that the capital market, which is already at its lowest level, may further shrink, thereby increasing capital losses and eroding capital gains, which will also negatively impact FBR revenue from tax on capital gains. Considering all of these factors, it is more likely that the impact of these proposals on FBR revenue will be negative, as potential tax revenue from natural increase in companies profits, dividends and capital gains will be more than the increase in tax collection due to withdrawal of tax rebates.


While I am hopeful that aforementioned proposals that do not make any economic sense will be reversed, I am actually amazed that such an anti-savings step, which negates the government policy of promoting formal sectors of the economy, investments and savings was proposed in the budget. 

Categories
Loading...
Suggested Blog Posts
Loading...

Befiler

how to become tax filer in pakistan

online ntn registration in pakistan

Income Tax Return

File Taxes

E-filling & NTN Registration

The easiest & quickest way to become a filer online. Register NTN, file income tax, check your FBR tax return. Filing taxes in Pakistan has never been easier before.

Tax Questions & Tools

Salary Calculator

NTN Finder

FAQ

Blog

Contact Us

Tax Services

Befiler Tax Filing NTN Finder Salary Calculator income tax return tax refund tax preparation sales tax return filing e file income tax calculate tax return filing online file a tax return free tax online tax

accounts, amnesty, befiler, blog, business, calculator, capital, earning, excise, expense, fbr, filer, financial, house, income, invest, law, ntn, online, organization, pakistan, portal, property, returns, salary, sales, scheme, service, tax, withholding, AOP, Business registration, Online Preparing Tax Filing, NTN registration, NTN Verification, Salary tax calculator, FBR tax filing, Tax return, E-filing

logo dashboard image how to make ntn in pakistan how do i check my fbr return online benefit of filer pakistan how to open my fbr account without password atl status fbr fbr tax return last date pakistan income tax calculator last date for income tax returns pakistan salary tax pakistan taxation fbr tax rates pakistan sales tax rate ntn certificate fbr Befiler – Your Smart Tax Assistant for Income Tax Return Filing NTN Registration with Befiler is Fast and Easy! Why You Should Become A Filer Information Needed to File an Income Tax Return More Incentives, More Reasons to Become Filer Online Tax Filing Culture in Pakistan : A Trend on the Rise Befiler’s Role in Improving Tax Awareness and Education in Pakistan How Do I Become a Tax Filer in Pakistan? Federal Budget for Financial Year 2019 – 2020 TAX AMNESTY SCHEME 2019 TAX FILING FOR SALARIED INDIVIDUALS Important facts to know about NTN Registration Making Tax Simple for People Befiler Makes You a Tax Filer with Ease Pakistan’s Tax Culture Strategy for FBR Transformation and Enhancement of Tax Collections How I should Benefit from Becoming a Filer in Pakistan? Filing Income Tax Returns: Late Filing is Better than Non-Filing and Notices from FBR. File your Tax Returns Online with Befiler Calculation of Taxes on your Salary Tax Credit and Deductible Allowances: How can you Pay Less in Taxes and Save More? Exemptions and Tax Concession: How to Legitimately Remain Safe by Paying in Less or No Taxes Online Correspondence of Tax Notice: Real-time coordination with the Tax body: Nadra and FBR Joining Hands Together To Track And Hunt Non-Filers Sales Tax: Its Fundamental Concepts, Those Who Are Required to Register for Sales Tax, and Basics of Sales Tax Registration. Why you should integrate your POS System with FBR? Implications of Finance (Supplementary) Bill 2021; Get to know which commodities are going to get costlier! Single Sales Tax Returns: A New Sales Tax Returns Portal Finance Supplementary Act 2022 Business NTN Registration Process: How I can Register my Business NTN in Pakistan conveniently? Company Incorporation Process: How I can Register my Company in Pakistan with Ease? It’s the time to profile non-filers: FBR’s bid to launch “Asaan Tax Portal”. Offences, Penalties, and Prosecutions: You can land in hot water, if you failed to comply with filing tax returns. Withholding Taxes in Pakistan: Why it is Important to Educate Yourself, and how can You get a refund on your paid Withholding Tax Money? Calling out Freelancers: Government registering them for controlling Money Laundering Prime Minister’s relief package, a sigh of hope for the nation PM Imran Khan to distribute Rs. 407Bn Interest-Free Loan under Kamyab Pakistan Program Tax Amnesty Scheme 2022 Intellectual Property: Interesting and Relevant Things to Know About Topic: Companies: Its types, basics, purpose and registration benefits. Reviving Sicked Industrial Sectors through granting Tax Incentives FBR’s measures to facilitate people https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=22&per_page=10 https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=7&per_page=10 https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=21&per_page=10 https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=18&per_page=10 https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=20&per_page=10 https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=17&per_page=10 https://www.befiler.com/blog/?category=1&per_page=10